First up in our serialised results of the BBAs 2024 is a big one in the bar world - American Whiskey. Here's how it went...
In the American whiskey category, Uncle Nearest made a wide field feel narrow, taking three of our top five overall scores. It was the Tennessee-based brand’s Single Barrel Rye that stole the show, with a fine overall score of 77/100.
Our specialist panel scored it gold on taste, noting “spice”, “nuts”, with a good “balance of fruity sweetness”. It took silvers in design and value for money. Yet on score alone, it wasn’t the best-tasting product in the category – that accolade went to family member Uncle Nearest Uncut & Unfiltered Straight Rye, which took 45/50 on taste on its way to an overall score of 72/100.
The panel picked up on moreish flavours of “vanilla ice cream” and “marshmallow”. Joining the podium was Whistlepig 10 Year Old.
This Canadian-American hybrid was noted for its spicy apple palate with a long finish and its more than reasonable price, but it was the design that struck gold.
Fourth spot went to Uncle Nearest 1856 Premium Aged, a place up on last year. Its “creamy toffee” flavours and “smooth body” earned it a silver, which it matched in design.
Rounding off our top five was another rye – Sagamore Signature Cast Strength. Described as having “chewy”, “toffee”, “spicy” and “sweet” qualities, it took the third highest score on taste.
For more on the how the BBAs works, visit here.